About Research Events Experts Newsroom Currency of Ideas
Milken Institute | Newsroom | Currency of Ideas - INET Council on the Euro zone crisis vs. Mr. Draghi Currency of Ideas: INET Council on the Euro zone crisis vs. Mr. Draghi
July 26, 2012 at 02:58 PM
INET Council on the Euro zone crisis vs. Mr. Draghi
  Banking Europe Public Policy
  Posted by
Jakob Thomas
Jakob Thomas
 
This Monday (July 23), the Institute for New Economic Thinking, Council on the Euro Zone Crisis issued a noteworthy report, "Breaking the Deadlock: A Path Out of the Crisis". In it, the Council lays out with great clarity the structural causes of the Euro crisis, namely: divorcing monetary policy from fiscal policy and bank supervision, extracting money supply control from individual sovereigns, and eliminating exchange rate adjustments between members of the union.

Further, it essentially proposes two varieties of solutions. The first aims at more integration between Euro zone countries: a banking union with powers to supervise and, if necessary, dissolve banks; Euro-wide financial reform to refocus the financial system on economically beneficial activities; a "debt-restructuring regime" for countries troubled beyond rescue; and more fiscal surveillance by the European Parliament.

The second variety is familiar in that the Council essentially proposes to mimic the cooperation of the U.S. Treasury and Federal Reserve in financing government debt. Circumventing the complications associated with Eurobonds (i.e., the need for re-forging the ECB's statutes, enforcing shared responsibility for sovereign debt, etc.), they propose two alternative and complementary solutions.

First, the European Stability Mechanism (ESM) could be granted a banking license to finance itself through the ECB discount window. It would thus function as lender of last resort and be able to help troubled countries through crises -- that is, after current debt levels and capital flight is dealt with -- without requiring tedious alterations in European law.

Second, a "common risk-free asset", similar to U.S. Treasuries, could be issued by a to-be-created European agency, to cut the cord between a given sovereign and its banks.

In terms of the latter, the report falls a little bit short of explanation, referring to a 2011 paper on the subject (Brunnermeier et al., "European Safe Bonds"). The idea, in essence, is to create an agency that buys sovereign bonds (a nation’s debt) up to a fixed maximum that is linked to the country's debt riskiness and the size of its economy. The agency then issues senior and junior tranche bonds of its own, using the sovereign debt as collateral. The mechanism is given value by regulators assigning these bonds zero risk weight, and the ECB insisting on them as collateral. This would cut market frenzies out of the financing process of sovereigns and provide the financial system with an opportunity to flee into a different asset class instead of the different sovereigns.

In light of this, it is rather curious that Mario Draghi, the ECB’s president, would announce that the European Central Bank would do "whatever it takes" to save the Euro, only three days after the report was published. The markets, of course, rallied in a sort of knee-jerk reaction, as they usually do. But what did Draghi actually commit to? Nothing of substance. Instead he lectures about liquidity and risk aversion in the interbank lending market, which, he assures, has been "taken care of" with the ECB's Long-Term Refinancing Operations (LTRO). Draghi then goes on about the necessity of creating a European-wide deposit insurance system and supervisory authority, the establishment of which is outside of the reach of his power.

So, what was the purpose of Draghi's comments? To set the stage for the INET Council's proposals put into practice? To refocus the cause-of-the-Euro-crisis debate on things he can influence?

Only one thing is certain: with the ECB's statute prohibiting sovereign bail-out, Draghi's hands are tied.

Your Comment:






Please help protect our site from spammers, type the following number into the field below.

5 8 8 4 1  
      


Members of the press
may direct inquiries to:

Conrad Kiechel
Director of Communications
Phone: (310) 570-4668
Fax: (310) 570-4627
ckiechel@milkeninstitute.org

Skip Rimer

Executive Director of Programs and Communications
Phone: (310) 570-4654
Cell phone: (310) 739-7591
Fax: (310) 570-4627
srimer@milkeninstitute.org

 
 
About MI
 
About Us
  Careers
  Contact
  Download Annual Report
  FAQs
  Locations
  Our Team

Blog


Events
  Associates
  Conferences
  Global Conference
  State of the State
  Summits
    London 2013
    California 2013
  Forums
  Labs
  Young Leaders

Experts
Newsroom
  Latest News
  News Videos
  Press Releases

Research
  Centers
    Asia
    California
    FasterCures
    Financial Markets
    Israel Center

Initiatives

Publications
  Books
  Financial Innovations Labs
  Milken Institute Review
   Amazon Apps
   App Store
  Research Reports
  Viewpoints
  Search All Publications
Support MI
  Associates
  Donate
  Sponsorships
  Strategic Partners

Follow Us
  @Twitter
  Facebook
  YouTube
  Google+
  LinkedIn

Related Sites
  Celebration of Science
  Chairman's Corner
  Melanoma Research Alliance
  FasterCures
  Partnering For Cures

©2013 Milken Institute